Answering the Question of Homebirth
by Vanessa Turner

[Editor's note: This article first appeared in Midwifery Today Issue 93, Spring 2010.]

It is inevitable. In every single childbirth education class and doula prenatal meeting I lead, I am asked “the question.” It never fails. Sometimes a particularly well-read mother or partner asks it at our first meeting before we even start getting down to business. Other times it doesn’t come up until the last meeting, after we’ve watched videos of particularly beautiful births and are saying, “Goodbye, until the baby comes.” But most often the question is asked when we talk about interventions.

So what is this powerful question? In some way, shape or form, my clients ask, “Can I have a homebirth?” And, sadly, my response is always along the lines of: “What county do you live in?” Because in Western Pennsylvania where I live, teach and doula, homebirth midwives are no longer attending births or, at least, they’re not advertising their services. You have to know someone, who knows someone, who can put you in touch with someone.

Because I am a doula and instructor of hypnosis for childbirth, the majority of my students and clients are seeking a natural birth experience. The majority also are low-risk, younger than 40 and somewhat knowledgeable about birth. They come to me because they want a different experience than they have had with a prior birth or than the horror stories they have heard in the media or from friends. I teach them about all the terminology, the tests and ways to negotiate to get what they want. I talk to them about strategies to get care providers to slow down and listen to them and that, when all else fails, to bring a man in a suit (perhaps the father or grandfather of the baby) to intimidate their care providers into taking them seriously. I also ask them to consider where they are birthing and with whom and explain the midwife’s model of care. During all this I know the best chance they have to achieve their desired gentle, natural birth, is to give birth at home. But, living in Pittsburgh, they do not have that option.

While homebirth is not technically illegal in the state of Pennsylvania, meaning there are currently no laws regulating birth in the home, it is “alegal”—tolerated in practice, but midwives (traditional as well as certified professional midwives) can be ordered to cease and desist for practicing without a license. This leaves it up to the discretion of the local law enforcement to pursue cases against midwives who attend homebirths that result in transfers to hospitals or result in poor maternal or fetal outcomes. The profession’s questionable status combined with the prominence of several major medical systems in Pittsburgh has led to the prosecutions of a number of Western Pennsylvania midwives, making it nearly impossible to locate a midwife willing to attend a homebirth in this part of the state. The birthing culture here is a conservative, medically managed model of care. When I began researching resources for my students and clients in 2007, I was able to find only three midwives within driving distance of Pittsburgh and none were willing to be put on my referral list. Instead, moms-to-be network on local attachment parenting and natural living e-mail groups, posting requests for information on midwives and receiving referral information privately.

When I am with a birthing mother in her home, helping her to relax and nest, watching her go from uncertain to confident and comfortable in her temporary role, I cannot help but think about what is to come. How we will soon interrupt this wonderful birthing dance and move her to a new place with new people, bright lights and invasive exams and monitors. We are going to ask her to let go of her inward focus and answer questions about her pain level, contraction frequency and duration, and many other things so that “we” can figure out what her body is doing and how to “fix it” or make it go faster and “better.” How, when we arrive and check in, there is very little I, as the doula, can do to stop the cascade of interventions if, for some reason, her body takes longer than average to dilate, her baby descends more slowly than desired, or her urge to push is delayed or takes longer than is deemed “necessary.” It feels like a crime that this mother is not allowed to remain in her own space, with a watchful and respectful birth attendant.

As a doula, the best solution I have found is encouraging my clients and students to stay at home as long as possible. However, the expectation of having to move can prolong a labor if the mother is holding back or fearful about leaving the comfort of her home to transition into a new place. If this anticipation of moving causes tension, the mother may arrive at her birthing location and find she is not as far along as she had hoped—and the cascade of interventions begins.

For doulas, who are not able to perform dilation checks, it can be difficult, especially with first-time moms, to tell when the time has come to move from home to the birthing center or hospital.

A woman can experience transition-like sensations at different times during her birth, and it can be hard to gauge where she is without the luxury of additional time. While precipitous births in cars are rare, it is still something that can happen if the couple waits too long to transition out of the home. No doula wants to bear the responsibility of having suggested they wait longer.

The irrational “illegality” of homebirth robs women of the opportunity to birth unmolested. It robs babies of the opportunity to have a truly natural birth, and it robs families of the empowerment that comes from taking charge of their care. As a doula, I teach the ultimate contradiction: parents have the right and power to make decisions about their and their child’s care, but they don’t have the option to give birth in their own homes. But I’ve been getting “that question” more often, and more families here are beginning to stand up for their rights in hospital settings. My hope is that they will take this a step further and demand the right to birth at home.

Vanessa Turner is a professional doula and childbirth educator in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Normalizing homebirth and midwifery care as the standard for low-risk mothers is her passion and she hopes to become a CPM after her children are grown.


If you enjoyed this article, you'll enjoy Midwifery Today magazine! Subscribe now!

FREE Newsletters
Attend the Midwifery Today conference in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, April 2014
Want to reach midwives?
Advertise in Midwifery Today magazine.
Click here for more information.
Did you enjoy this article?
Receive more like it four times a year.
Subscribe to Midwifery Today magazine.
Promote your birth-related product or service.
Advertise with Midwifery Today.
Click here to check out all the options.
Through networking and education, Midwifery Today's mission is to return midwifery care to its rightful position in the family, to make midwifery care the norm throughout the world, and to redefine midwifery as a vital partnership with women.